(im)Mortal Failure
Daniel Pi proposed an
argument [
full thread] against God's existence. Briefly paraphrased:
Suppose God is necessarily both
immortal(unlimited life) and
omnipotent(unlimited power).
[A]Could God commit suicide?
[i]If so, then God is not immortal. [ii]If not, then God is not omnipotent.
Therefore, God (as defined) does not exist. Now, that
sounds airtight...until you think,
"Are mortals omnipotent?" (Not that I know...) After all, if an inability to die disproves omnipotence, then an ability to die proves it, right?
More specifically,
Could mortals commit suicide, and if so, does that entail omnipotence?
To take the first part,
Could mortals commit suicide?:
Yes. Why? Because mortals are able to die, it is definitely possible, and unless mortals had
no power whatsoever, they can not avoid death by themselves. (Observation shows that some mortals
do commit suicide.) Therefore, mortals could commit suicide.
So does that entail omnipotence? No. Mortals are already limited by the fact that they
can die. Moreover, though suicide is a special case of death, it does not require a special amount of power. (It just requires
some power.)
Therefore, if mortality does not entail omnipotence, then immortality
must entail it. What does this say about the original question [A]? It means that [A] [ii] is incorrect. If God could not commit suicide, it is
at least possible for God to be omnipotent.
[Note: this does
not prove God's existence, but only that this particular argument does
not disprove it.]
Discuss.