Saturday, June 04, 2005

from Wikipedia's entry on Karla Homolka:


Common misconceptions


There are several misconceptions that show up in the media, in internet chat rooms and on various web pages and bulletin
boards regarding Karla Homolka.



  1. Karla Homolka was diagnosed as a psychopath.

    • This is not strictly true. Although she has often been described as such, Homolka's multiple diagnoses as a psychopath have
      never come from a) trained psychiatric professionals who b) treated her directly.

    • The parole board that reviewed Homolka's case in 2001 did refer to her as a psychopath, but these were not trained
      psychiatric professionals. Numerous other psychologists and psychiatrists have termed her a psychopath, but none had ever
      actually counseled her directly, resorting instead to interview transcripts, case reports, video documentation, and/or newspaper
      articles.

    • She was directly evaluated by doctors Hans Arndt, Alan Long, Andrew Malcom, Chris Hatcher, Stephen Hucker, Peter Jaffe and
      Angus McDonald, all of whom were in agreement in terms of her diagnosis as a battered wife suffering from severe clinical
      depression and post traumatic stress
      disorder
      . In fact, Dr. Sharon Williams, an expert on incarcerated sex offenders and psychopaths, and who evaluated her
      between 1996 and 1999, concluded that Karla Homolka was not a psychopath, and not a danger to reoffend.



  2. Karla Homolka never received any treatment while in prison.

    • Homolka participated in every treatment program recommended, until she was asked to participate in a program that had been
      designed for male sexual offenders. She refused, on the grounds that she was neither male nor a sexual offender (since she had
      not been convicted as such).



  3. Karla Homolka's time in prison was filled with parties, and she has done nothing to better herself during that
    time.


    • Homolka took nearly every recommended course and treatment (with the aforementioned exception) during her incarceration, such
      as "Improving Your Inner Self", "Anger Management", "Survivors of Abuse and Trauma", and many more. She also earned her
      bachelor's degree in psychology from Queen's University, and achieved very high grades.

    • At one point, a released inmate leaked photos which showed Homolka at a birthday party. Since Homolka was, at that time,
      being held in the medium-security Joliette Institution for Women, such birthday parties were common. When the photos were
      published, the resulting uproar led to Homolka being placed in solitary confinement. It should be noted, however, that Homolka
      was not the first Joliette inmate to have a birthday party, nor was she the last, nor was it clear that it was even
      Karla's birthday party portrayed in the pictures.



  4. Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo created snuff films.

    • By definition, the movies created by Homolka and Bernardo are not snuff films, because they do not show the murders of their
      victims.



  5. Karla Homolka has never expressed any remorse for her crimes.

    • Homolka expressed remorse numerous times. Most notably to her family in a letter to them regarding the death of her sister
      Tammy, and to the doctors treating her throughout the years. In fact, in letters to one of her previous psychiatrists, she
      described in length the continuing nightmares she had regarding the two murdered girls. Whether this remorse is genuine or
      feigned cannot, of course, be reliably determined.



  6. Karla Homolka began a lesbian relationship in prison with a woman who had likewise been convicted of helping to rape
    and torture young girls.


    • On September 22, 2000, the
      Montreal Gazette published an article on Homolka's prison
      life which gave the impression that Homolka was in a lesbian relationship with convicted child-rapist Christina Sherry (in fact, the
      article was accompanied by a photo of Homolka and Sherry together, which no doubt reinforced this particular misconception). In
      fact, Homolka's lesbian relationship was with Lynda Verroneau, who had been convicted of participating in a bank robbery. The independently wealthy Lynda Verroneau would later sell pictures and stories to the media
      claiming that Karla had pretended to be her lover in order to get lingerie and a computer.



  7. Karla Homolka enjoyed (or, alternately, was horrified by) the events that took place.

    • Homolka's "level of enjoyment" of course, cannot be judged. Neither argument; that she enjoyed the crimes, or that she was
      horrified by them, is entirely supported by the evidence. Both sides claim conclusive evidence for their argument, but only
      Homolka herself knows for sure.



  8. When Karla Homolka gets out of jail, she is going to ...

    • Many people - including the authorities of many Canadian provinces - would like to know what Homolka's plans are for life
      after prison. However, she has not told anyone anything; therefore, any rumors are just that - rumors. On Tuesday, April 27th, 2005 the Niagara Regional Police sent two officers to meet face-to-face with Karla to
      discuss her plans upon release. Other than saying that she was "Co-operative," no other details have been released.



  9. The Internet has a great many Karla Homolka fan sites.

    • On April 09, 2005 the Toronto Star published a story about a supposed "Internet Frenzy" regarding Karla
      Homolka. Although some new sites had popped up in the beginning of 2005 some had also gone
      away. The article intimated that there were several Homolka "fan sites"; however, after investigation by at least one internet
      community
       (http://p097.ezboard.com/bkarlahomolka), only one
      site
       (http://www.geocities.com/karla_holmolka_fan) was found which could be
      classified as a fan-site.



  10. The home videos were discovered after the plea-bargain had been fixed. Had they come to light earlier, she would have
    been sentenced to life in prison.


    • This is vastly oversimplified. Prosecutors had an opportunity to both "break the deal" and charge Homolka with additional
      crimes for a period of 8 months between when the tapes were found and authorities agreed not to charge her with additional
      crimes. The police were in possession of the tapes in September of 1994, although the "deal" had been signed in 1993 (and they
      had been working under the deal under a verbal agreement long before that) they were still able to prosecute her for "Jane Doe", and for lies that they uncovered in her earlier testimony (an absolute
      deal-breaker was lying during her interviews with prosecutors) since they knew she had lied; Stephen Williams published memos where the Crown discussed these lies amongst themselves. Officials
      agreed not to prosecute her for the "Jane Doe" incidents, and they chose not to break the deal with Homolka on May 18, 1995. That
      decision was final.



  11. Karla Homolka will be released on Leslie Mahaffy's birthday.

    • It is entirely likely that Homolka will be released before July 5th (which is, indeed, the birthday of Leslie Mahaffy). It appears that the Canadian prison system has the authority to release her as early as June 24th, 2005 but she may be released no later than July 5th, 2005.



2 comments:

  1. Anonymous11:35 PM

    we as a society are so quick to pass judgement let he with out sin pass the first stone this young ladies only crime was that she knew that this man was doing all these bad things and she went along with it who did karla rape who did she kill her sisters death was an accident not murder there is a difference she has paid her dues just leave her alone and let her live her life in peace congrats karla on your knew motherhood

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous11:49 PM

    for the anonymous poster above, first of, your grammar and punctuation does not allow your point to come across as i am sure you intended. i would be interested to know if this poster is female. i am fascinated by your supposition that she has "paid her dues". i am not sure how many months of prison it takes to make up for human lives, i would be interested in hearing exactly how many. there must be a conversion chart somewhere.
    karla will always have her apologists, just like people will always write serial killers and beg for their hand in marriage. at least those people are being honest about their predilections, and not trying to make excuses. karla deserves even MORE time, in my opinion, because she was NOT propelled by an uncontrollable rage- she did what she did simply to keep her man. to me that is FAR more disgusting. stop pretending people-karla allowed her boyfriend to rape and kill her own sister, and she was MUCHO aware of the rest of his crimes, indeed, exalted in it. do not make excuses. you say she wasn't convicted of these crimes. charles manson wasn't convicted for murder either, but he STILL should be in prison. if her only crime is the knowledge of the crime, these crimes are so horrible to be plenty enough to lock her up and throw away the key. "Congrats on your new motherhood"? I WEEP FOR THAT CHILD.

    ReplyDelete